A three-judge panel of the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals was in town today to hear (among other cases) a U.S. Dept. of Justice (DOJ) appeal of a local district judge’s ruling in a habeas corpus case involving an ICE detainee.
Oral argument took place this morning at the federal courthouse in downtown St. Paul. Your correspondent was there.
Jose Fernando Juares Velasquez is an illegal alien Guatemalan citizen residing in Minnesota. He was arrested by ICE in January 2026 as part by Operation Metro Surge. By the time a habeas corpus petition was filed on his behalf, Velasquez had already been moved to Texas as he awaited deportation to Guatemala. That he was not in Minnesota when his habeas petition was filed was a fact known and acknowledged by his lawyers. Nonetheless, the Minnesota-based federal judge granted the habeas petition and as a result, Velasquez was released. Velasquez is back residing in Minnesota and free from deportation. None of these facts are in dispute.
The DOJ maintains that the district judge should have transferred the case down to Texas, where Velasquez (the corpus) was physically present, in keeping with past U.S. Supreme Court precedent. The judge did not. The DOJ is asking the 8th Circuit to over rule the Minnesota district judge’s order.
The lawyer for Velasquez maintains that the issue is moot. The DOJ complied with the original order (as they do in every single instance, without exception) and as a result, released Velasquez, and the case (File No. 26-cv-597) is now closed. But that would mean that the DOJ could never appeal a habeas case.
It did not appear that Velasquez himself turned up for today’s hearing. He has not obtained any legal authorization to remain in America, but because of the judge’s ruling, ICE cannot enforce any deportation order.
The 8th Circuit panel should reach a decision within the next few week.
In the meantime, I’ve been tracking all of the habeas cases filed in Minnesota since the last 8th Circuit ruling on the subject back in late March. So, far, that represents more than 500 habeas petitions. Outcomes from the 506,

Local ICE detainees represent a veritable united nations,

