Yesterday, I wrote about how local, state, and federal government are increasing your property taxes. As we noted in our recent report, “Supplying Hope and Demanding (Real) Affordability: An agenda for Minnesota’s future,” this is one of the major pressures on affordability in Minnesota, that squeeze on people’s budgets, and we proposed two solutions.

First, we began by noting that property taxes are payments for locally provided services like roads, police, and schools. To the greatest extent possible, these services ought to be paid for by those who use them, whatever their age and whatever the status of their mortgage. The payments for these services ought to change with the cost of providing them. This cost will change due to increases in the population and/or prices.

So, to get property taxes under control, we believe that state and local policymakers should:

  • Restrict property tax increases to the rate of population growth plus the rate of inflation growth.

In a city with a budget of $10 million in Year 0, for example, and forecast population growth of 2.0% over the coming two budget years and a forecast inflation rate of 2.0$ in Year 1 rising to 3.0 percent in Year 2, its budget would grow by 4.0% in Year 1 and 5.0% in Year 2 for total growth of 9.2% over the two years, as illustrated in Table 1. The result would be that per capita spending would increase by only the rate of inflation; it would remain static, in real terms.

Table 1: Budget growth with population + inflation formula

Source: Center of the American Experiment

There could be local catastrophes that necessitate increases in local government spending above the rate given by population + inflation. In this case, local governments would be able to put the increase to a vote of their residents, much as school district referendums can raise property tax rates to pay for operating costs, building renovations, and technology needs. Neither is it certain, on recent performance, that these referendums would be doomed to fail.

Capping local government spending increases is not sufficient, however, when state government is free to increase local fiscal burdens by imposing unfunded mandates. To prevent this, we propose that state and local policymakers should:

  • Place a limit on unfunded mandates.

In 2017, an analysis by David M. Primo and Jake Jares from the Mercatus Center at George Mason University noted that “Over a quarter of the states place some constitutional limits on mandates, and most provisions were enacted in the 1980s and 1990s,” so this is a workable policy. Examining shortcomings in Florida’s constitutional prohibition of unfunded mandates, Primo and Jares note that “details matter,” but conclude, also, that “the spirit of mandate rules is sensible, since the rules strive to prevent legislators from imposing new spending without having to account for how that spending will be paid for.”

Last November, I wrote that:

At present, state politicians can have their cake and eat it. Those who passed this tidal wave of unfunded mandates have been able to tout their role in providing paid family and medical leave or unemployment insurance for part time workers, while it has been people at the county level who have been tasked with finding a way to pay for it. The opprobrium for hiking property taxes is falling, unjustly, to a large degree, on them.

If we want to bring property taxes in Minnesota under control, we need to ensure that those who propose expansion of local government spending incur the political costs — or benefits — of financing it.





Source link