Please help to “Nuke the Mandate, Free the Nukes” by providing public comments by today on the MN nuclear energy study. The relevant website for submitting comments is here.
The Great Plains Institute (GPI) were contracted to undertake this study by the Minnesota Department of Commerce (MN DOC). The two websites for the study are here and here.
The remainder of this article is a ‘greatest hits’ summary version of my second submission of 32 pages and 6,988 words. My first submission of this inquiry was 24 pages and 7,719 words.
Technology and costs
A comprehensive Levelized Cost of Energy (LCOE) shows that nuclear generation at $37.18 per MWh is less expensive by:
- 2.4x than coal;
- 3.1x times than natural gas;
- 7.9x times than wind; and
- 13.3x times than solar.
Nuclear is, not only the least expensive, but it is the environmental best when it comes to total life cycle CO2; plus renewables are not without environmental costs, as documented by American Experiment in Shattered Green Dreams, including that wind and solar use:
- minerals from unsafe, unhealthy and polluting foreign sources;
- 10x more land area than nuclear, coal or natural gas generation;
- many hazardous and unrecyclable components;
- shorter operating lifespans than nuclear, coal or natural gas generation.
The Averch-Johnson (A-J) Effect is a well-known concept in economic regulation of a strong tendency, by public utilities and their regulators, towards “gold plating” of the capital base. The PUC system of electricity revenues and rates setting has been biased in favor of inflating the capital base throughout the 20th century, but has been biased ‘on steroids’ in favor of doing so through wind and solar renewables throughout the 21st century.
Siting and infrastructure
I believe NIMBYnomics offers some valuable insights. NIMBY stands for “Not In My back Yard.” This is a truly bipartisan phenomenon that helps block all sorts of economic development at the local level, and sometimes state and federal. Blocking data centers is the prime example of Bipartisan NIMBYism. Blocking wind and solar power and public housing are examples of Right NIMBYism. Blocking nuclear power and family housing are examples of Left NIMBYism.
The key to better understanding and addressing NIMBYism is Public Choice economics. One important insight from Public Choice is that special interests have greater incentives, of a monetary or psych nature, to be very active in politics. Economists call them “Bootleggers and Baptists.” “Baptists” are ideological activists, whilst “Bootleggers” are crony capitalists.
The issue of concentrated costs versus diffuse benefits is the economic root of the NIMBY problem. NIMBYs are motivated by strong incentives of concentrated costs, monetary and psychic. Development advocates are motivated by weaker incentives of dispersed benefits. NIMBY “Bootleggers” can often be bought off at the right compensation price and in the right institutional circumstances. NIMBY “Baptists” sometimes and increasingly cannot.
Minnesota Management and Budget (MMB) and the Public Utilities Commission (PUC) should be encouraged, sooner rather than later, to create official guidelines on cost benefit analysis (CBA) and economic impact analysis (EIA). MMB has a CBA webpage with links to reports but no guide. PUC has an EIA webpage with a ‘motherhood’ statement but no guide.
In the meantime, MMB and the PUC should first look to the MN Department of Transportation’s CBA guide, sample values (including on CO2) and example spreadsheet. For even greater depth and breadth of CBA and EIA guidance, MMB and the PUC should also look to the international ‘gold standard’ of the Handbook of Cost Benefit Analysis by the Australian Department of Finance. This nuclear energy study should also do the same.
The MMB website claims that “Minnesota is a leader in evidence-based policy making.” Whether that is true or not, MMB, the PUC and this study should all refer to another international ‘gold standard’ on this topic, and again from Australia. That being a landmark speech by the former Chairman of the Australian Productivity Commission (PC), Professor Gary Banks A.O., entitled Evidence-based policy-making: What is it? How do we get it?
Development timelines
The recent midterms resulted in a win for now Governor-elect Amy Klobuchar. Her campaign platform priorities of most relevance to “new nuclear projects” are reproduced below:
Lower Costs for Minnesotans. As Governor, Amy Klobuchar will work to lower costs that have been going through the roof across the country — essentials like…utility bills. … And she’ll hold the line on utility bills by modernizing Minnesota’s power grid and adding more affordable, renewable energy.
Make Government Accountable and Root out Fraud. Amy Klobuchar intends to transform our state government to be innovative, effective, and accountable. … It means modern technology that delivers results fast. It means making it easy to start a business and bring good-paying jobs to Minnesota. It means turning the page on a bureaucracy that leaves people dreading having to jump through hoops to get a permit or start a business.
Allowing for “new nuclear projects” is very consistent with these priorities, especially if “adding more affordable, renewable energy” can include clean energy, as in carbon clean, as in nuclear energy.
Note also that Senator Klobuchar has a webpage devoted to Competition Policy that states:
Strong competition policy is necessary to build a vibrant economy that works for consumers, for workers, for entrepreneurs, for local communities, and for companies, large and small.
I wrote about Australia’s public utilities related Competition Policy in October 2026, which concluded “public utilities” are not so “public” and “natural monopolies” are not so “natural.”
Additional Information
Context matters. And when it comes to why the moratorium on new nuclear power should be lifted, context is crucial. Therefore:
- Wind and solar renewables are still, as of 2024, vastly more costly than nuclear, coal or natural gas reliables (see Chart 1 below).
- The growth of MN renewables in the 21st century has far outpaced that of the rest of the midwest (MW) region and the country (US) as a whole (see Chart 2 below).
- Twin Cities (MSP) electricity CPI inflation has thus, also far outpaced that of the MW and US in the 21st century (see Chart 3 below).
- MSP electricity CPI inflation has outpaced MSP general CPI inflation throughout the 21st century, as well as overtaking it in the 2010s and 2020s (see Chart 4 below).
Therefore, and in conclusion, the time is nigh to “Nuke the Mandate, Free the Nukes!“
Chart 1

Chart 2

Chart 3

Chart 4

Image Source: Nuclear Power? Yes Please

